Hadrian won the Face Off.
Colbert
Face Offs: 50
Wins: 27
Losses: 22
Ties: 1
No City, XX
All Face Offs
5
Votes
Stewart
Face Offs: 1
Wins: 0
Losses: 1
Ties: 0
No City, XX
All Face Offs
4
Votes

A judge's decision against the 5 second rule for dropped food and for a new 30 second rule is not only reasonable, it's fair.


You hear it everywhere - the sound of a piece of food hitting the ground, immediately followed by someone yelling, "five-second rule!" The prospective eater must then pick the food up off the floor and make one of life's most difficult decisions: to eat, or not to eat.

The fast food industry made their decision. The 5 second rule rules. A judge disagrees.

"Food gets dropped", said industry spokesperson Eton Moore. "Lots of it would go to waste without the 5 second rule. If we had to throw away every food item that hit the floor, that would slow down our service and drive up our costs. However, more than 5 seconds would also slow down service. Ad it would put our customer's health at risk".

Friends of the Handicapped has a different view. "Not all of the people working at a fast food restaurant can retrieve a fallen food item in just 5 seconds", says FOH spokesperson Floe Down. "Some people need more time".

FOH brought suit in federal court to force the fast food industry to allow workers more time to pick up fallen food.

Judge Ima Judge ruled in favor of FOH, citing the need for reasonable accommodation for handicapped workers while still protecting public health.


While there is a compelling need to assist the handicapped regardless of their occupation, the clearer interest is that of public health. If I am going to a restaurant and paying money for their service, I should be able to expect, at a minimum, clean food. Dirt is not a condiment, neither is bacteria. By accepting my money, the restaurant is agreeing to a contract.
What strikes me most about this issue is that the court allowed the practice of picking up mishandled food as an option at all! Workers in my state must wear gloves, handle and measure food with approved devices and use an approved disinfection process. How is that in the interest of public safety?
The court ruling is not reasonable in any way, as it contradicts common sense and promotes unsanitary conditions.


In ruling in favor of Friends of the Handicapped, Judge Ima Judge cited testimony of Anne Bernhard, an assistant professor of biology at Connecticut College. Bernhard and her students put the rule stating that food can be picked up and eaten if it doesn't remain on the ground for more than 5 seconds to the test.

The research team dropped apple slices, a wet food, and Skittles, a dry food, on a cafeteria floor and measured the results. They concluded that 30 seconds was probably safe for moist food and up to a minute could be safe for dry food. [1]

Berhard testified that it would be safe for a burger to be on the floor for 30 seconds and a bun for 60 seconds. Judge Judge ruled that 30 seconds for retrieving fallen food was the standard the fast food industry should follow.


So quality in America has come down to whether or not an item would contain deadly bacteria? The study itself limits itself to only known deadly bacteria such as e. coli. There are other factors not accounted for such as the cleanliness of the floor and where the food falls. The study did look at chemicals that may be present on the floor The study itself did not use a regular floor. Quoting the article: ???They said that previous confirmation of the 5-second rule was not real world as the floor in question was deliberately smeared with E.coli.??? Clearly there are more factors that can cause sickness than one type of bacteria. If I had recently disinfected my floor to protect against e. coli (say with Lysol) does that mean I should sell food soaked in it?

Does dirt on food not count as contamination? People regularly send food back for reasons that are more scurrilous than having dirt on the food. This ruling will increase that process and result in higher costs for consumers and a less pleasant dining experience.


In other news, research by the University of Arizona last year found the average office desktop harboured 400 times more bacteria than the average office toilet seat. They also found that, compared to men, on average women have three to four times the amount of germs in, on and around their work area.

Microbiologist Dr Peter Wilson said a keyboard was often "a reflection of what is in your nose and in your gut".

So, when meeting up with a colleague at a fast food restaurant, it seems you should be more concerned with not shaking their hands than with an extra 25 seconds your food was on the kitchen floor.

And perhaps laptops should be banned from restaurants as well!


[1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/7377002.stm


It seems that you are trying to argue that people eat laptops, or toilet seats. Or other people's hands. They don't. You might. Most don't. People encounter them, touch them, but do not consume them.

The simple prevention here is to do what your mom said and wash your hands before you eat. You are responsible for keeping your hands clean, not the restaurant. Why? Because they're your hands. They are responsible for keeping their food clean. And presumably their hands. (Most wear gloves these days to prevent transmission.)

You can wash your hands. Washing your Taco Supreme is counter-productive.

Comments

Add Your Comment
Colbert

[1] http://www.shortnews.com/start.cfm?id=62969

Report Offensive Comment
Fdr

It sounds unreal. I doubt this has any truth.

Report Offensive Comment
Obama-button

lol thats the point tremontdemocrat, hadrian always makes these insane false and halarious claims. And wins becuase it is so damn funny =D

Report Offensive Comment
Tancredo

KefkaZ, please don't take anything Hadrian says to be 100% serious, the best debates with him invovle an equal amount of satire and shenanigans

Report Offensive Comment
Colbert

MorgMcA: Judge Ima Judge agrees!

Report Offensive Comment
Stewart

Well, I'll be sure to bring some humor into the next argument.

Report Offensive Comment
Mccain

Well... that's the last time I crave fast food. I think we have at least a right to clean food, and it is disgusting that resturants are allowed to do this.

Report Offensive Comment

Post A Comment

Please keep it clean. Bad words will get filtered, and offensive comments will be removed.


or cancel

TIME PHOTO ESSAYS

TIME cover JFK

More than 50 years of cover stories about the 35th President


The Brazen Pirates of Somalia

This year, close to 90 ships have been seized in and around the Gulf of Aden, more than triple the number of 2007

(Jason R. Zalasky / US Navy / EPA )